Refurbished phone grades describe one thing only: how much visible wear there is on the frame and glass. At Refurb Phone the three grades are Fair, Good and Excellent. A Fair phone has clear marks, a Good phone has light marks and an Excellent phone has few or none. Inside, all three are the same: every device passes more than 80 checkpoints, has at least 80 percent battery health and comes with 24 months warranty. This guide explains what each grade looks like, who should pick which, and why a case changes the answer.

Refurbished iPhone 15 Pro Max in white titanium showing frame and glass condition

What a cosmetic grade does and does not tell you

The grade is a cosmetic rating. It is assigned at the end of the refurbishment process, after the device has already passed every technical test and had any faulty part replaced with a working one. The person grading the phone looks at the frame, the front glass and the back glass under good light and records what they see.

The grade does not tell you anything about the battery, the cameras, the speakers, the screen's image quality or how the phone performs. Those are identical across Fair, Good and Excellent because every phone must pass the same checkpoints. If you want the full picture of what happens before grading, read how we refurbish a phone with 80+ checkpoints.

In short: the grade changes what the phone looks like and what it costs. It does not change how it works or how long it is guaranteed.

Refurbished phone grades compared

Fair Good Excellent
Frame Visible scratches, scuffs or small dents on the edges and corners Light scratches or scuffs, visible on close inspection No marks or very faint marks that are hard to find
Front glass Visible scratches, none affecting the image or touch Faint micro-scratches, visible only when the screen is off and held to the light No visible scratches
Back glass Visible scratches or scuffs Light scratches No visible scratches
Display image Fully working, no dead pixels Fully working, no dead pixels Fully working, no dead pixels
Touch, cameras, speakers, buttons, ports Tested, all working Tested, all working Tested, all working
Battery health Minimum 80 percent Minimum 80 percent Minimum 80 percent
Data wipe and lock check Yes Yes Yes
Unlocked for Three, Vodafone, Eir Yes Yes Yes
Warranty 24 months 24 months 24 months
Return period 14 days 14 days 14 days
Price Lowest Middle Highest

Read the table bottom to top and the pattern is clear. Everything below the first three rows is the same. The only variables are the marks you can see and the price you pay.

Fair: the practical choice

A Fair phone has lived a life and shows it. Expect scratches on the frame, scuffs on the corners and visible marks on the glass. On a dark background, with the screen off, you will see them. With the screen on, they disappear behind the image. The display itself is fully working, with no dead pixels and no touch issues, because those are technical faults and a phone with technical faults does not pass.

Fair suits people who care about function and price more than appearance. It is a sensible pick for a child's first phone, a work phone that will be in and out of a pocket all day, a backup device or anyone who is going to put it in a case the moment it arrives. Once the case is on, a Fair phone and an Excellent phone are hard to tell apart.

Good: the middle ground

Good is the grade most people end up choosing. The phone has light signs of use. You might see faint micro-scratches on the glass when you tilt it to the light, or a small scuff on one edge. Across a room, or in normal use, it looks like any other phone. It is a comfortable balance between price and appearance.

Good suits daily users who want a phone that looks well kept without paying for a near-perfect finish. If you use a clear case or a slim case that leaves the edges partly exposed, Good is usually the grade where small marks stop being noticeable.

Excellent: as close to new as a refurbished phone gets

An Excellent phone shows no visible wear or only the faintest marks that you have to search for. The frame is clean, the glass is clear. It is the grade for people who want the phone to look the part, who plan to use it without a case, or who are giving it as a gift.

It costs more than Fair or Good because clean devices are less common and in higher demand. What you are paying for is the finish. The technical state, the battery minimum and the warranty are exactly the same as on a Fair phone.

Who should pick which grade

  • You will use a full case from day one: Fair. The case hides the frame and the back. The screen looks the same on every grade when it is on.
  • You use a slim or clear case: Good. Light marks on the edges are mostly covered, and the back glass is protected.
  • You use no case: Excellent, or Good if you are comfortable with a few faint marks.
  • Phone for a child or teenager: Fair. It will pick up marks of its own soon enough.
  • Gift: Excellent. First impressions matter when the box is opened.
  • Work phone or second phone: Fair or Good. Function is what counts.
  • Trading in or reselling in a year or two: Good or Excellent, as cosmetic condition affects what you get back later.

How a case changes the calculus

A case is the single biggest factor in choosing a grade. Most cosmetic wear sits on the frame, the corners and the back glass. A standard case covers all three. The front glass is the only part left exposed, and when the screen is on, light scratches on the glass are not visible behind the image.

So the question becomes: how often will you look at your phone with the case off and the screen dark? For most people the honest answer is almost never. In that situation, paying for Excellent buys a finish you will not see. A Fair or Good phone with a good case gives you the same screen, the same cameras, the same battery guarantee and the same 24 months warranty.

The reverse is also true. If you dislike cases and keep your phone bare, the frame and back are on show every day. Excellent is the grade that will keep you happy, and Good is a reasonable compromise.

What to check when your graded phone arrives

Whatever grade you choose, give the phone a quick inspection on arrival.

  • Compare the cosmetic condition with the grade description. Fair phones will have marks, that is expected. An Excellent phone should not.
  • Turn the screen on and check that the image is clean and the touch works everywhere. This is the same on every grade.
  • Open Settings and check battery health is 80 percent or higher.
  • Insert your Three, Vodafone or Eir SIM and make a call.

If you feel the grade does not match what you received, you have 14 days to return the phone. Technical faults are covered for 24 months regardless of grade. Our full 10-point checklist for a newly arrived refurbished phone goes into more detail.

Frequently asked questions

Is a Fair grade phone less reliable than an Excellent one?

No. Both pass the same 80+ checkpoints, both have at least 80 percent battery health and both carry 24 months warranty. The grade describes marks on the frame and glass, nothing else.

Does a Fair phone have scratches on the screen?

It may have visible scratches on the front glass. They do not affect the image or the touch response, and they are not visible when the screen is on in normal use.

Does the battery differ between grades?

No. Every grade has a minimum of 80 percent battery health. The grade is purely cosmetic.

Which grade is the best value?

For most people who use a case, Fair or Good gives the same experience as Excellent at a lower price. Excellent is the right choice if you use no case or want a gift to look new.

Can I return a phone if I am not happy with its cosmetic condition?

Yes. You have 14 days from delivery to return an online purchase. Technical defects are covered separately by the 24-month warranty.

Are all grades unlocked?

Yes. Every phone we sell is unlocked and works with Three, Vodafone, Eir and any other network.

Shop refurbished phones by grade

Each listing shows the grades available for that model. Pick the one that fits how you will use the phone, with the same testing and the same 24 months warranty on every grade.

Still comparing sellers? Read our guide to the best place to buy a refurbished iPhone in Ireland and our explainer on what refurbished means.

12 novembre, 2026 — Refurb Phone